{"examinations":[{"id":"d6cb7fec-39e2-40c3-9bd0-f94464c3b94e","exposureId":"e5bb7839-4ec0-41b3-87c6-0bd408ba6dae","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:10:29.896+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with rim ligaments breaking into numerous airborne droplets. No central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"80439645-ced9-479a-b954-152f3a711517","exposureId":"43e4e960-3120-4d0b-8a2a-2e09186cda20","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:11:54.827+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with an irregular, breaking rim. Numerous detached droplets are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"80e72fad-a8eb-4556-ba4d-dd670459c9d1","exposureId":"9c680a82-7852-40c9-9a4c-171ff8f51ae8","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:12:38.536+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers terminating in droplets. Numerous detached secondary droplets are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"ce1ec55f-7b19-4ce9-b3e5-45e615c5c0bf","exposureId":"fe0f2a2f-fb6a-4f4e-b0df-9bc758ae25da","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:12:52.388+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim fingers breaking into numerous airborne droplets. A central liquid column rises from the cavity floor.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"2b837f17-218a-459c-9ed5-0b522a273ab9","exposureId":"3aaf56df-9cf1-443d-8e4c-7bb48d4c5e18","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:13:28.524+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Several concentric developed crowns show beaded rim breakup, with abundant detached droplets above and across the surface. A central cavity and extensive radial ejecta are visible.","protocolConsistency":56,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"6295f213-f20b-4d55-b9fd-e468de057c4a","exposureId":"15c2cb24-b61d-4d86-8d7f-f0449df3a7b1","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:14:12.521+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. Rim ligaments, detached droplets, and outward ejecta are clearly visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"5c7a30f1-7da7-4273-908a-ec548c31f8b3","exposureId":"ae98a2eb-60ed-470f-81e9-1f0650879f54","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:15:26.031+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with a beaded rim and numerous detached ejecta droplets. The rim shows active breakup and irregular folded liquid sheets.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"b0345f27-dcfa-467f-8aa0-490ad87e0f10","exposureId":"23891e25-92ed-4acc-8b9b-13d8bfc6b3b5","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:15:59.7+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"Two developed concentric crown structures with tall, bead-tipped rim fingers are visible around a central contacting mass. The rims remain largely continuous, with no clearly detached ejecta.","protocolConsistency":45,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"7490d612-6a78-4f1b-8a8e-6a7eb517a9d1","exposureId":"ea25acbc-684b-41dd-a2ed-0d07c6d44c48","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:16:10.338+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A developed liquid crown surrounds a central hemispherical mass. The rim is breaking into numerous elevated droplets and ligaments.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"bba2c8cd-9953-4516-ac6a-0035612cec23","exposureId":"36a0df3b-203c-494f-8cf2-2047a81865f0","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:16:27.829+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown and open cavity are visible, with rim fingers breaking into numerous satellite droplets. No central rebound column or intact primary drop is visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"f03740aa-d431-469a-9a19-3cc6746d9fcd","exposureId":"328ffdce-9a81-4f02-9a85-dd9c920df928","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:16:43.202+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad developed crown has a strongly fingered, breaking rim with numerous detached ejecta droplets. A central column terminating in a large rounded drop rises within the impact cavity.","protocolConsistency":46,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_DURING_EMERGENCE","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"92f026f7-844b-4ce0-ba9b-d043fef437ba","exposureId":"8ad83fad-5fcb-416d-9391-f8c862ebaf40","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:17:09.438+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with an irregular rim separating into numerous airborne droplets. No central column or intact primary drop is visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"69dcd2cb-c56a-4518-834b-3d9abf213973","exposureId":"3288d18f-9002-4a46-a46c-64efa3b66e9f","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:17:50.189+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity. Rim ligaments terminate in droplets, with numerous detached secondary droplets above the surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"0edeae33-acc1-4b69-8d83-8ccb515628f2","exposureId":"dde99c55-459a-485c-9f22-73f478464118","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:18:30.466+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers and numerous detached droplets. Active rim breakup and secondary ejecta dominate the plate.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"7f40d01c-9aaa-45ea-854c-24f062385d30","exposureId":"2526e331-7761-4842-86ad-fd75036c5cf2","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:18:41.506+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with irregular rim fingers, tip beads, a stretched liquid filament, and detached secondary droplets. The rim is visibly fragmenting.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"25ff69fc-d240-4111-bb24-94befb7bcc47","exposureId":"6148ec4a-328d-4ff8-b43e-22bd50440cee","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:19:03.186+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a visible cavity. Rim ligaments are breaking into numerous secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"2d7744ca-4730-43da-aecb-7a490bdd8925","exposureId":"ae9bcc87-79a3-470f-ae24-d8574f2a0e53","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:19:13.854+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with a fingered, beaded rim. Numerous detached droplets above and around the crown show active rim fragmentation and ejecta.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"8b063a96-884c-4b7a-8413-421ebe466e95","exposureId":"f5d560ff-f5ae-4db5-96a7-18d800a5d8d2","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:19:34.184+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed outer crown and smaller nested crown are visible, with fingered rims and numerous detached droplets above the surface. The rims are actively fragmenting into secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":56,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"f55fa33a-7b94-4c9e-ab28-34c718256a24","exposureId":"89980c1f-e82f-44b3-8fac-c5dc92f0553b","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:19:47.253+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall central liquid column rises from within a developed crown. The beaded rim is fragmenting into numerous secondary droplets above a strongly disturbed surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"04df107d-1dee-4112-b746-d4b89ae20db6","exposureId":"7aff8f6d-8e9a-4965-b4f4-a2e564ef337a","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:20:04.107+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with an irregular fingered rim. Numerous detached droplets and rim-tip beads show active fragmentation and secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"f70cb48f-4e67-47f1-8548-750c6313554e","exposureId":"dd435c9d-6e97-4e11-a777-57d6d8cef1a5","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:20:27.469+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central column, with rim ligaments and numerous detached droplets above the surface. The rim is visibly fragmenting into secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"9e58a2a2-3a58-4f5e-bb08-90f2d6f25c8e","exposureId":"45256f2c-49b5-4547-a4ee-32be95174d9d","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:20:57.591+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown with a raised central structure is visible. The rim bears ligaments and detached satellite droplets, indicating active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"c29c1ba1-81c0-45b2-ba1f-bbc1db458da7","exposureId":"88d4dad0-ea5b-4646-8799-73a348b1b194","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:20:59.83+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad developed crown surrounds a smaller central crown, with extensive rim breakup. Numerous detached droplets and radial ligaments are visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"f842cb28-167c-4ed6-aaae-993c5bfb5302","exposureId":"9780fa17-d5d0-434b-9a7c-7c188808c03d","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:21:40.2+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown has elongated, breaking rim fingers with numerous airborne secondary droplets. A prominent central liquid column rises within the impact basin.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"2a6ab2b6-4134-4f2e-9b2c-ced81a01ecbb","exposureId":"e27be82a-d83b-43f2-831a-4c31050df821","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:21:48.435+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central cavity and contacting rounded body. The rim has elongated ligaments and numerous detached secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"45894cc8-4386-4714-9e1c-aa445ab2079e","exposureId":"dcf25b1c-0297-427c-aadf-504fd10cd54d","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:22:00.779+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds the central impact region, with torn rim sheets, elongated ligaments, and numerous airborne droplets. The rim is undergoing clear fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"414d376a-5050-471d-8684-cd935534936b","exposureId":"07f6cce1-6f83-4db3-8975-da1f7045b6e7","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:22:13.9+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity. Rim fingers are shedding numerous discrete secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"564851f7-39c2-49c1-857a-be5a2c150b7a","exposureId":"f6546b8c-d9d2-45f3-beff-8f652e354083","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:22:25.534+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":95,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A large central liquid mass contacts the target surface within a developed splash crown. The rim is breaking into sheets, ligaments, and numerous airborne secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"c6b065df-8693-4c5c-99bb-32b2df13180d","exposureId":"0594cdf0-5a38-490c-b21b-f069cba4c1e5","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:22:38.22+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown has a perforated rim with numerous detached ejecta droplets. A central descending liquid column and strongly displaced surface are visible.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"846f7892-4cad-4e08-af85-b682cec0bc74","exposureId":"662858bb-74a8-4691-86e8-f8bbac874d3a","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:22:51.919+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":93,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown with multiple concentric rims surrounds a central cavity. Rim fingers terminate in droplets, with detached secondary ejecta visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"e0511856-a223-46af-a22f-dcd244354769","exposureId":"439391a6-988f-42b7-8e42-7ea47f697c3a","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:23:48.537+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large intact drop is separated well above a developed crown and cavity. The crown rim is fragmented into numerous secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"24aecbf2-ddd4-4d56-b0f0-06b5d7b6337b","exposureId":"2426f3b4-d99b-4634-85e9-484fba014bdd","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:23:50.82+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds the central impact region, with an irregular rim producing numerous sheets, ligaments, and airborne droplets. Extensive secondary ejecta indicates rim fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"58317e5d-de61-4854-aaa0-687849e1a29d","exposureId":"86a28feb-f964-4cb3-8ecf-92b58f5bc5c0","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:24:35.338+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown rises around a broad impact cavity. Rim ligaments and numerous detached ejecta droplets show active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"8ea3cb3f-d0ac-4f0b-84fe-42e91b03ccef","exposureId":"75bfb57f-5e31-4dcb-819b-4d4ef2ef9e91","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:26:11.709+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with extensive rim breakup and numerous airborne secondary droplets. A central liquid column hangs within the cavity.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"891e0f7d-42d3-41b2-8c62-eb986ca62d75","exposureId":"c81c7a63-bfeb-432c-ada3-11b8b4bdbf33","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:33:29.966+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown surrounds a broad impact cavity. The rim carries ligaments and beads, with numerous detached secondary droplets visible above and around it.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"9043a3a8-bda7-42d0-9081-cf4639343bd3","exposureId":"40c4227f-e9f9-4b6f-9d38-6f3f3d221595","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:49:58.778+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall central liquid column rises from a developed, irregular crown. Fragmented rim tips, airborne secondary droplets, and broad surface ripples are visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"2847b8f1-7b18-4475-91cb-00fafd7f9baa","exposureId":"43a617b7-b538-4687-9587-91852bd85e3e","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:57:28.707+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A developed circumferential crown surrounds the central impacting mass. Rim ligaments are breaking into numerous airborne secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"082e58aa-a1e4-4378-87d5-3f5179e377ad","exposureId":"091b6f6d-4d88-44b1-8368-43451cf65705","createdAt":"2026-08-14T19:59:13.919+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v1","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with the rim divided into elongated ligaments. Numerous detached droplets and satellites are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"28659dcf-aa7d-42da-9dc9-39bccfb0e149","exposureId":"09c9af72-ca1a-44ba-b109-a9723607ed01","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:14:40.86+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular liquid crown rises from the disturbed surface, with a large central opening. The rim bears ligaments and detached satellite droplets, indicating active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"128118be-e606-47da-a432-785f608f4d6a","exposureId":"8def706d-6193-489e-b3bb-576ded04d30f","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:15:22.872+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall, narrow central liquid column with a bulbous attached tip rises from a disturbed surface. No developed crown, cavity, or detached ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"e3b707bb-fe19-40fb-b5e6-42c79f23e40a","exposureId":"a307152c-0f2e-4ed7-b994-e8a7394a3abc","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:16:25.718+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with an irregular rim producing numerous detached droplets. No primary drop, central column, or rebound drop is visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"30514a43-104b-403e-adec-e4c728285571","exposureId":"4400d154-83d9-45f6-913e-67cfb2ace069","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:17:00.116+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with numerous detached droplets and beaded rim projections. A suspended inward-spanning liquid sheet bears a central pendant tip.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"a40d3d54-ff9d-4501-86dd-ab8ff3c14a7a","exposureId":"5952a649-2760-49a5-b1b9-e97e9c77968e","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:17:49.954+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown has thickened rim lobes shedding numerous secondary droplets, with a central liquid column rising from the cavity. A large detached drop is overhead, and a separate narrow column stands at left.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"c07770e0-4621-4ca2-98c6-fa62ec7403c2","exposureId":"d4024766-66f0-4df5-8b0b-83606a7fff45","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:19:04.278+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":93,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad perforated liquid crown is elevated around a central column. The rim terminates in ligaments and numerous detached droplets, showing active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"8796a312-f1e9-46ff-bf55-440f7909ad7f","exposureId":"05731db6-2d10-44bd-8464-4e723b683026","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:22:54.061+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with a tall scalloped rim and bead-tipped projections. Scattered secondary droplets and radial liquid sheets are visible around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"75285b09-14ec-4404-bb89-dd2fac717959","exposureId":"a15a9105-3d6a-4ab6-bd20-dfb087e6e4d2","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:24:48.88+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed red crown surrounds a broad smooth white central dome. The crown rim bears elongated fingers and detached secondary droplets, showing active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"651c406a-5b49-4b60-a2c4-4538966a1e0b","exposureId":"b422e29b-2bf7-43d6-9bbb-1a8c82539c57","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:27:14.952+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a central white dome, with numerous rim ligaments terminating in droplets. Detached secondary droplets are distributed broadly above the disturbed surface.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"08c41e0b-11fa-42b6-a131-3d30d3ec600e","exposureId":"53b16591-fb51-4847-84c3-35e508be09ea","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:28:14.594+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed liquid crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with rim ligaments breaking into numerous airborne droplets. One larger detached drop is visible above the crown.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"e3759573-882f-4867-bd85-1a916da048c9","exposureId":"55d5100b-db91-45df-9f1a-74b7969d95dd","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:31:14.874+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown encloses a visible cavity, with irregular rim fingers breaking into numerous airborne droplets. A large detached droplet is suspended above the crown.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"f9c9baba-9c63-4c3e-9d6d-88205cd1385f","exposureId":"1e5da301-1992-4436-ac80-2c6571eee25f","createdAt":"2026-08-14T20:44:45.712+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad developed crown surrounds a central pale dome. The rim is beaded and breaking into numerous airborne droplets and ligaments.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"7b4403cd-ea82-4c53-a4d8-9afa6698ccdc","exposureId":"f36eb2fd-0525-45f3-85c4-a2fe2bb5a569","createdAt":"2026-08-14T21:54:10.44+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad central dome, with elongated rim fingers breaking into numerous airborne droplets. The target surface is strongly disturbed with residual radial rippling.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"c6f63515-7828-41e4-8f27-df406daa234b","exposureId":"b3ae8b8a-873d-4cbf-a327-739fc77ff26a","createdAt":"2026-08-14T21:55:31.773+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":82,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed central crown-like structure rises above a disturbed cavity, with separated droplets distributed above and around its rim. The rim terminates in multiple beads and projections consistent with active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"bdc70e80-7264-4455-b00d-2584e57ea81c","exposureId":"ce4359eb-1ee8-4e4f-8628-0d6f96d2fea2","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:13:26.786+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown has elongated, beaded rim projections with abundant detached droplets. Several central liquid columns rise from the disturbed cavity, including bulb-tipped columns.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"18225e6f-e8c1-41e4-a941-ce25575504e0","exposureId":"14378438-e444-4e88-98c1-3276d6b09b6b","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:15:26.092+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Developed red and pale liquid sheets rise around a disturbed cavity, with a thick central column. The rims are stretched into ligaments and numerous detached ejecta droplets.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"2cb02e74-bb5e-4178-876a-7ae243352f8e","exposureId":"0424a02b-0232-4335-96b9-7b79dc96932b","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:18:14.301+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":93,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a depressed central region containing numerous vertical liquid columns. Dense suspended droplets and rim lobes show extensive fragmentation and ejecta.","protocolConsistency":39,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_DURING_EMERGENCE","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"0d8a212e-1b07-4671-9ce0-e5c72f271a28","exposureId":"e73884e6-2bad-43b0-a63b-e9fcb2ebb6c0","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:18:35.076+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central cavity, with elongated rim fingers breaking into numerous airborne droplets. A narrow central column terminates in a rounded rebound drop.","protocolConsistency":4,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"f49e5bea-aa88-4ef7-87c5-2d78815a61de","exposureId":"f7f3b0a7-9b63-4ced-8072-f3dd0d76c674","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:18:56.67+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed perforated crown surrounds a narrow vertical liquid column. The rim is breaking into radial ligaments and numerous detached droplets.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"96d46758-1e6f-4342-b41c-2d3a8f0a57f2","exposureId":"2a54575d-9fb6-4b79-8a0e-2815b4096afa","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:19:28.858+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim bears ligaments and bead-tipped projections, with numerous detached droplets above the surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"1f444a03-e829-4a9c-8ac6-a9434b941de8","exposureId":"e40b63b7-135c-4ed8-9961-66a9016e23cd","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:25:41.587+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A large central dome contacts the liquid surface within a developed crown. The rim terminates in ligaments and numerous detached droplets, with broad surface deformation around the impact site.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"d7448c2a-ffda-417e-a6a9-a6b318a742c4","exposureId":"77207aec-adf1-4e4c-879b-4b90664f2bee","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:28:16.041+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim fingers terminating in droplets. Numerous detached secondary droplets are visible above and around the fragmented rim.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"aa01c53e-c1e9-4c38-b8f9-fca27977637c","exposureId":"f40cda94-f3b6-4f94-a18d-03777fe2eccf","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:30:04.468+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central pale dome, with elongated rim fingers breaking into numerous airborne droplets. The target surface is strongly displaced around a visible impact cavity.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"db454c09-4c86-4972-be37-910d6e37090a","exposureId":"20fe9293-6787-45a6-add5-13ea519acf45","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:39:26.941+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a central cavity. The rim bears multiple ligaments and detached secondary droplets, indicating active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"2e04ecf8-4a41-4da3-911e-f54c2c168a74","exposureId":"29a0b621-7e57-4030-8828-a1e25eaf0cf7","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:41:21.95+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown has broken into radial ligaments and numerous satellite droplets. A broad central liquid column rises within the disturbed cavity.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"1244dec1-4f56-46a7-ac91-378aa1b8a4a2","exposureId":"790aedde-67c4-445a-9a27-f4ae076083c3","createdAt":"2026-08-15T00:43:13.861+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with rim fingers terminating in droplets. Numerous detached ejecta are visible above the disturbed surface.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"0405df31-9f85-4404-91db-cd07dc3e5317","exposureId":"cdd0ab06-d4d2-4c9f-aaa2-fa81b7285e9e","createdAt":"2026-08-15T02:21:40.034+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad impact cavity, with elongated rim fingers and numerous detached droplets above the surface. The rim is visibly fragmenting into secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"dd0f42fd-206e-4d1d-8806-e92f8fb65a90","exposureId":"7bef7307-67af-4ea0-800a-8c145675f1ba","createdAt":"2026-08-15T02:25:37.944+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"indeterminate","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Several intertwined, bulb-tipped liquid columns rise from a disturbed cavity, with numerous detached droplets around them. The configuration does not resolve reliably into a canonical impact stage.","protocolConsistency":null,"contradictionLevel":"unresolved","contradictionCodes":["INSUFFICIENT_VISUAL_CERTAINTY"]},{"id":"2a1e4ca6-3178-420d-bbaf-4f78b7cb72e8","exposureId":"5a0f4226-17a3-4967-a53e-73bb0d0f7996","createdAt":"2026-08-15T02:27:31.822+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall, narrow central liquid column rises from a locally disturbed surface with low radial ripples. No developed crown, cavity, or detached rebound drop is visible.","protocolConsistency":35,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"2df20b0e-e44c-4a84-8223-f8c44efe6204","exposureId":"6abe94b5-81f3-4019-805e-1c7190b4c13f","createdAt":"2026-08-15T02:28:28.873+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall, developed crown with perforated liquid walls and ligaments rises from a strongly disturbed surface. Numerous detached droplets surround the rim, showing active fragmentation and secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"dc5460d8-f0c2-4ccc-ac26-53290c7d9feb","exposureId":"f8d76cd6-53a8-48d9-9658-4b5eccf408b8","createdAt":"2026-08-15T11:43:10.817+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central column, with numerous detached droplets and ligaments indicating rim fragmentation. An elevated perforated liquid sheet forms a wheel-like network above the crown.","protocolConsistency":46,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_DURING_EMERGENCE","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"7d3ad68a-02fc-45f3-ba4e-e50ec78000c5","exposureId":"117c88dd-2184-431d-971e-df3edb2879d2","createdAt":"2026-08-15T11:44:28.373+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed circular crown has a beaded, fragmenting rim with numerous secondary droplets above and around it. A short central column terminates in a rounded rebound drop within the cavity.","protocolConsistency":46,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_DURING_EMERGENCE","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"78ee9e0d-b44e-4083-b755-04c5a8662e2f","exposureId":"d819d3f6-63fa-4ba5-8547-083a90b57bce","createdAt":"2026-08-15T12:03:15.838+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity. Rim ligaments terminate in droplets, with abundant detached ejecta above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"e10dbfd1-218d-4ab6-82d8-b43624ab39d8","exposureId":"046cfd39-b58f-48b4-bb4f-51c3cbf8370f","createdAt":"2026-08-15T12:06:42.78+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers shedding numerous secondary droplets. No intact primary drop or central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"59ddffee-0ad9-41af-aab0-4a187724447a","exposureId":"bf73c91b-7260-4b1c-9e86-f51619092d53","createdAt":"2026-08-15T12:14:32.834+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":87,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a visible cavity, with beaded rim projections and detached droplets. A broad, thin liquid sheet is suspended horizontally above the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"55955780-5f30-4ac8-b6cf-2752782c502a","exposureId":"0775207f-02fd-449a-88b4-4db8898eff7e","createdAt":"2026-08-15T12:27:23.353+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. Rim tips are beaded and breaking into numerous airborne secondary droplets, especially on the right.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"644b3688-a393-408f-a28e-4b734c9424f4","exposureId":"c782ab4c-09c6-4dbe-b2b0-92c7231c993c","createdAt":"2026-08-15T23:35:25.079+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with an irregular fingered rim. Numerous detached droplets are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"18171926-dd81-4d9e-ad1d-5887098e883f","exposureId":"50671002-ea9d-4bf1-ae6a-1d0f6d86a0b6","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:19:00.286+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall central liquid column rises from within a developed annular crown and cavity. The rim is beaded and fragmented, with numerous secondary droplets surrounding it.","protocolConsistency":45,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR"]},{"id":"0d071122-7d06-4738-8fff-35c2343a0dca","exposureId":"70b8218f-a519-447b-9da3-018e947adaac","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:21:05.613+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity. Rim fingers terminate in droplets, with numerous detached secondary droplets above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"abcdf9db-9869-4945-9f9f-292aa81f9119","exposureId":"15e8ea15-d900-4aea-b6e6-d020129be2ca","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:21:48.638+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall central liquid column rises from within a developed crown and cavity. The crown rim is beaded and ejecting numerous secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":45,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR"]},{"id":"4d891443-1d67-4bef-9ad1-2a2c96a92174","exposureId":"4955201c-093f-4386-9193-1b0dbdfd98ed","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:22:02.368+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A large rounded liquid mass contacts the disturbed surface within a developed crown. The crown bears elongated rim fingers, with numerous detached droplets dispersed above and around it.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"4a046ab9-b526-46a1-9aaa-0e0af98f50c8","exposureId":"83011369-db6d-46de-929a-1ced6e379763","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:22:35.713+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers and numerous detached droplets above and around the rim. The target surface is strongly disturbed by radial ripples.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"10bb8dce-520e-4bfa-830e-9e6c53fce244","exposureId":"6a96e734-61d4-4ec0-a13d-8b11a6f38b5e","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:23:13.94+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a deep central cavity. The irregular rim is separating into numerous airborne droplets and ligament-like projections.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"596f38ac-ad09-41ad-a854-e374d511ea18","exposureId":"2d249ad4-6614-4bbc-8d12-3e894d908ded","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:23:29.644+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown and central cavity are visible, with rim fingers breaking into numerous airborne droplets. A narrow central liquid projection rises within the cavity.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"3ee13dc6-847b-41f2-9ba5-62c2e1652228","exposureId":"5f4c7c05-9cc3-4e43-8e1e-cff040f70873","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:24:06.288+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers terminating in droplets. Numerous detached secondary droplets are visible above and around the fragmented rim.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"c8a36618-56c1-43af-8a13-982f31aba540","exposureId":"ae01ee07-d99f-4a3c-8975-0e53fb60449c","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:24:11.951+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad developed crown surrounds a visible central cavity. The rim is extensively fingered and breaking into numerous secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"b6e094f9-2024-408e-b90c-fcaafc6a87a8","exposureId":"b94b5001-247f-42ad-96e1-c9b344dfe83e","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:24:32.771+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The beaded rim is fragmenting, with numerous detached droplets visible above and around it.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"f825608d-a6c8-48ca-9f4d-838e58a12f1e","exposureId":"7d5e6059-c489-47ee-b1f0-24decb541553","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:24:49.471+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim ligaments terminating in droplets. Numerous detached ejecta are visible above and around the crown, and a small central column rises within the cavity.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"83a1cad0-2fe7-491c-9e37-ee5225936e12","exposureId":"714401c2-726e-4edf-ac54-1f402e5d4c30","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:25:29.434+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim bears elongated, bead-tipped ligaments, with numerous detached droplets above the surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"38c97135-6102-427d-8e66-c2b6a3aadef6","exposureId":"952351bf-9895-45a0-a44f-f246f1b13b39","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:26:13.161+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":93,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A central white hemispherical liquid body contacts the surface within a developed red crown. The irregular rim is breaking into raised ligaments and numerous detached droplets.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"90d6c966-6654-4f78-99b1-976f11db94c5","exposureId":"4b815f52-41a3-4d16-bea5-6bcd27109315","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:26:25.174+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad lower crown with a beaded, fragmenting rim and lateral ejecta surrounds a central dome. Above it, a second detached umbrella-like sheet is linked by central droplets and curved liquid columns, presenting incompatible temporal structures in one plate.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"d78da1dd-1ba3-44f8-b6ec-e9b326f44482","exposureId":"85d7b2a3-0e76-42d9-87fb-845862ea9520","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:28:41.396+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A broad smooth central dome contacts the disturbed surface within a developed annular crown. The crown bears elongated rim jets and numerous detached droplets.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"e05d11ac-f72f-43e2-8eb6-458e87d87ab5","exposureId":"f54d9107-6deb-46c5-90ed-d3ed3cdda83f","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:29:40.954+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad cavity is enclosed by a fully developed crown with a beaded, irregular rim. Multiple droplets are detached above the rim, indicating active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"0b0037a7-4192-430a-9425-66dce300ac83","exposureId":"81cf3138-8aa1-4647-80cc-2cb6eabeda09","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:29:53.818+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The raised rim bears numerous intact radial fingers with rounded terminal beads; no detached ejecta or central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"3ea3fb34-76f4-48ea-92a0-8669b458d47b","exposureId":"aa0e5455-7608-4ea5-98d5-db36dfa45add","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:30:32.279+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular rim surrounds a tall central rebound column, with detached droplets above and around the impact site. The rim is lobed and locally fragmenting, while the target surface shows a disturbed cavity and concentric rippling.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"5d2841e8-a11e-4c90-ad80-eb565f85525f","exposureId":"cb1279e5-cb75-4857-8d49-015bfc476ab8","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:31:02.874+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed red liquid crown surrounds a broad smooth central dome. The rim has numerous ligaments and detached droplets, with secondary ejecta distributed above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"56ad04ba-f51a-4f3d-be9b-25dd2a980281","exposureId":"c7a37291-4567-4ffb-8476-fa9e57994845","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:31:44.487+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity. The rim carries elongated ligaments and is shedding numerous secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"e777f8ef-633b-49bc-ac04-65a664bcd509","exposureId":"10c320cc-5215-4855-a4f1-877fe4a176c9","createdAt":"2026-08-16T07:41:35.487+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large detached drop hangs above a developed crown and open cavity. The crown rim is fragmenting into numerous satellite droplets, presenting incompatible pre-impact and fragmentation cues.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"e15e575f-5a11-4cc5-be5b-2ffaa4bcee43","exposureId":"bd69b237-8643-4f85-ae68-017b3588094b","createdAt":"2026-08-16T08:55:05.669+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed circular crown surrounds a smooth central dome. Rim ligaments terminate in droplets, with several detached secondary droplets above the crown.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"ad788e4a-81ac-4c0e-9674-1e0363482c24","exposureId":"a83b3c45-d1c2-45d9-a67a-40834be7f8f7","createdAt":"2026-08-16T13:22:46.708+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":93,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Several nested, developed crowns with fingered rims coexist with abundant airborne ejecta and a central rebound protrusion. The concentric crown structures do not resolve into a single impact stage.","protocolConsistency":38,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"689b9691-4213-4d5b-84a8-93c8bd3b32c5","exposureId":"cde2dbe1-c5e9-4bc9-9ce9-963484cdfdd4","createdAt":"2026-08-16T17:43:05.505+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim ligaments breaking into numerous airborne droplets. One larger detached drop is visible above the crown.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"eeb2d922-848a-401b-9f20-7e5eaadc3eac","exposureId":"5d4a6c00-d8f6-4488-ab6f-58cf5afce07d","createdAt":"2026-08-16T21:12:48.855+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity. The rim is beaded and breaking into numerous airborne secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"f465bb15-7645-410d-a01d-126b2d793162","exposureId":"cc8c4a30-b6df-439e-962f-d40344fccabc","createdAt":"2026-08-16T21:22:51.592+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":true},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a large smooth central liquid dome. The rim terminates in ligaments and droplets, with abundant secondary ejecta concentrated to the right.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"627bcee0-14a3-4e0e-a0cf-45eae9f07044","exposureId":"6489aa0e-8618-4fc7-9840-9c5c0fec862c","createdAt":"2026-08-16T21:24:00.155+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with irregular rim fingers breaking into numerous airborne droplets. Extensive secondary ejecta are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"a47f9b4a-0b7d-4bac-9b55-f7c8fa2dbb7e","exposureId":"d16e46a3-691b-4b64-818b-d4d5b3710b43","createdAt":"2026-08-17T00:32:50.446+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central depression, with an irregular, broken rim. Numerous detached droplets are visible above and around the impact site.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"4f6bc3b5-a23a-496d-aa12-44add9cc5542","exposureId":"eae83d2b-b261-49b3-b68b-1c5417a55c14","createdAt":"2026-08-17T13:16:51.095+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":92,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed red liquid rim surrounds a smooth white central dome. The rim bears elongated ligaments and detached droplets, with pronounced breakup on the right.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"e387a1a7-e120-49d1-aacf-bf59fedbc1ae","exposureId":"3dc9677c-5b56-451d-90c7-09ffbf455992","createdAt":"2026-08-17T15:19:49.208+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":83,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed low crown surrounds a surface cavity, with bead-like rim breakup and detached droplets. A large upright annular white structure contacts the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"e4a2cb84-708b-4290-b4ce-4e2961c40b87","exposureId":"d7d6b984-5521-425e-a616-b81263c0b1cd","createdAt":"2026-08-17T15:30:26.352+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":95,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The irregular rim bears projecting fingers and detached secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"1626cb1b-412b-46d1-97c0-3af5d5e6f5ac","exposureId":"2a1617b7-ac08-443c-a31e-e57b5b5bb818","createdAt":"2026-08-17T15:31:34.668+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim fingers, detached satellite droplets, and a thin liquid filament spanning two elevated rim tips. The rim is visibly fragmenting into secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"b2aae71e-6238-48ef-b732-1e8fefe188a6","exposureId":"f1e5d79e-129f-4a76-b56b-d29d8a10da7c","createdAt":"2026-08-17T15:32:44.054+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim spikes disintegrating into numerous airborne droplets. One large detached drop is visible well above the crown.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"11d1d0bb-7ad0-4485-9501-aff5841baa6b","exposureId":"fc0a70c9-6f95-4b35-aafd-057f8a0e688e","createdAt":"2026-08-17T15:34:59.488+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"aftermath","examinerCertainty":82,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A detached spherical drop hangs above a broad, irregularly spread and bubble-marked liquid layer. A shallow central depression remains, with no developed crown, ejecta, or central column visible.","protocolConsistency":22,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR"]},{"id":"d9bc8dc4-a65f-4837-8077-da8b6bbc4306","exposureId":"e104d007-718f-4493-ac01-6f505847562d","createdAt":"2026-08-17T15:36:34.192+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad developed crown is breaking into radial ligaments and numerous secondary droplets. A central liquid column rises within the disturbed cavity, with droplets aligned above it.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"0d6079fb-02cf-4cda-be1b-179130822e67","exposureId":"3a574f43-556d-4830-a43a-ec1a93d253bd","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:09:48.637+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single elongated primary drop is visibly separated from a level, unbroken liquid surface. No deformation, cavity, crown, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"972d6ace-cb00-4318-ae9f-804c061f9891","exposureId":"671b287d-db9d-4645-9619-56b3c5943dc1","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:10:59.652+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim ligaments terminating in droplets and numerous detached ejecta above. A short central liquid column rises within the cavity.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"5cf7262a-58c1-4cb6-b803-75c2efaa842b","exposureId":"5e3f0fec-9919-49fe-b521-473a501c3e3d","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:11:46.997+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"indeterminate","examinerCertainty":82,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous narrow liquid column joins a bulbous central base surrounded by a broad, flattened radial spray and fine ejecta. No discrete primary drop, developed crown, or visible cavity is present.","protocolConsistency":null,"contradictionLevel":"unresolved","contradictionCodes":["INSUFFICIENT_VISUAL_CERTAINTY"]},{"id":"bbc87cd7-6ee5-4627-aab4-34844f572119","exposureId":"6c8e28a7-0c92-418c-b162-1c1c090ccde8","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:12:38.772+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a central cavity. The rim has elongated ligaments bearing numerous detached and attached ejecta droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"0156b914-a41e-4d78-b65b-d1293957bf93","exposureId":"015a0f5e-a3fc-48f8-862b-b68b45e3d858","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:13:29.489+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim is beaded and breaking into numerous airborne secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"6cced0a3-0c65-47f3-876c-b747e60e7d20","exposureId":"59c6b73d-d799-4108-bc46-fb0ca7d7e57d","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:14:08.579+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown with bulbous rim projections surrounds a central vertical column. Detached droplets, widespread ejecta, and a disturbed pool with a visible depression are present.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"3dc3fd06-9fb5-4352-b4a7-f720ffe383e0","exposureId":"3af5df5a-ee77-4869-a128-bae5548160cf","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:15:18.801+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single spherical drop is clearly separated above the target surface. No contact, cavity, crown, ejecta, or surface deformation is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"661e1470-0977-4473-a343-311835f5a229","exposureId":"3f05f2a1-505e-40dd-8530-cc35095903e5","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:16:11.857+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":93,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a central cavity beneath a continuous vertical liquid column. The rim carries radial filaments and numerous detached secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"92142123-1a74-4622-80cd-2729e01f0b24","exposureId":"e355c79c-ee0d-4a3a-87d1-1b102984ab9a","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:17:04.691+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central rising column capped by a rounded rebound mass. Rim fingers, detached droplets, and a disturbed cavity-bearing surface are visible.","protocolConsistency":36,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","REBOUND_DURING_EMERGENCE"]},{"id":"f32c3d2c-9545-447d-b402-d1a7076d83b0","exposureId":"58c1fc4d-4227-4622-9a17-28a185be18ae","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:18:46.748+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"An elevated liquid sheet on a central column has an irregular rim extended into branching ligaments and detached droplets. Numerous secondary droplets surround the fragmented structure.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"1bf98d6b-793f-4ec5-8279-e1fcfb37b5bd","exposureId":"e49f179f-e9a7-4b2b-b366-ed687c6adc0c","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:19:52.884+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single rounded drop is visibly separated from a smooth oval liquid target. No surface deformation, crown, cavity, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"466702e4-2a3c-4385-8820-a54b299741d4","exposureId":"1920684b-3c5c-4604-aaea-6f3a8008ef73","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:21:31.381+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers and numerous detached droplets above the surface. Rim breakup and secondary ejecta are clearly visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"09a7aeab-2158-48d0-91bb-60ad74432626","exposureId":"f9d11dfa-86ca-40d5-bb50-21e8a066202f","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:23:19.381+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":92,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown with beaded rim projections and detached ejecta surrounds a central cavity. A broad, flat liquid body is separately suspended above the crown, presenting a configuration not resolved by a single canonical stage.","protocolConsistency":45,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES"]},{"id":"d4851e43-c7be-4f7c-a3d4-071508ef8bb8","exposureId":"76c47a1b-0934-4e74-aaa3-b6b8c58532b8","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:25:37.966+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. Rim fingers terminate in droplets, with abundant detached ejecta above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"ae10333f-4490-4ed8-80c8-1426d51126c1","exposureId":"841ea967-2286-486c-a007-c5a65ff999ba","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:27:08.141+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a central cavity, with rim fingers breaking into numerous outward droplets. A narrow vertical liquid column remains connected to the impact center.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"44806149-fd24-4a9b-baf0-598cb27dde64","exposureId":"a36ddcbf-a8a2-4ed0-aa96-d27f51976bb1","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:28:24.025+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central vertical liquid column, with an open depressed interior and broad radial sheet. Rim tips are breaking into numerous outward secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"3a58675c-bd3b-48b3-89a6-45816291fdbe","exposureId":"f1e14d3e-48bb-46de-ad92-900adf57f1e5","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:44:30.373+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"indeterminate","examinerCertainty":84,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A narrow vertical liquid filament extends from the upper frame into a flared central contact region, with broad radial sheet disturbance and scattered ejecta. No discrete primary drop or developed crown is visible.","protocolConsistency":null,"contradictionLevel":"unresolved","contradictionCodes":["INSUFFICIENT_VISUAL_CERTAINTY"]},{"id":"31c7bbdf-5323-4471-b018-531138a653fe","exposureId":"a91952be-f079-4b4f-bc83-ba7f3be71d4d","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:45:09.455+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall, narrow central liquid column rises from a shallow circular cavity bounded by a low crown. Fine droplets and broken rim elements are visible around the impact site.","protocolConsistency":45,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR"]},{"id":"45308e4e-d28a-404f-908c-53677f277e0a","exposureId":"3538d043-0c9b-4c69-a7d4-c4778aeae260","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:45:42.171+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed, fragmenting crown with rim ligaments, satellite ejecta, and a central liquid column occupies the wetted surface. Multiple intact droplets remain suspended above it in a regular array, presenting incompatible pre-impact and developed-impact cues.","protocolConsistency":38,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"a2beb5d2-83db-4653-861e-995f386a0dba","exposureId":"3dbf6ec8-2e87-436c-b5ab-859e4173f2a0","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:46:32.534+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall, narrow central liquid column rises from the disturbed surface and terminates in a large rounded rebound drop. No cavity, crown, rim fragmentation, or secondary ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"92425f2a-a6e4-4fed-b15b-1fcc41196b45","exposureId":"a08d42d0-76cf-4a10-96f2-d7c1aea54e17","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:47:42.744+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A spherical droplet is suspended above a strongly disturbed surface bearing a broad central liquid patch and radial splash residue. No developed crown, cavity, or central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":36,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","REBOUND_DURING_EMERGENCE"]},{"id":"e3341930-2d79-45fb-8edb-cc0cd30713d8","exposureId":"d6776cad-c22e-49af-bcb7-a94d0bc09eb8","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:48:50.752+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall, narrow central liquid column rises from a disturbed surface with concentric ripples and terminates in a large rounded rebound drop. No developed crown, fragmented rim, or secondary ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"5632bd7b-6664-43b9-99b8-63d6eac88085","exposureId":"f63027b6-8a90-4550-aa2f-3b2a6bf3d9e8","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:49:04.024+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall central liquid column rises from a disturbed sheet, with bulb-tipped radial projections and surrounding ejecta. A detached droplet is visible directly above the column.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"5be2adbc-d50d-4bd6-a5d6-648510cbb4ee","exposureId":"b282d294-9550-474c-a2aa-4e63dac1fa6a","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:50:24.254+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers and numerous detached droplets above and around the rim. The target surface is extensively disturbed.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"aa68592c-9fba-4686-be2a-b5cdbb0ac010","exposureId":"9771bcaf-02b5-47d9-a203-73fb34838f55","createdAt":"2026-08-17T16:55:51.307+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large drop is suspended well above a disturbed, textured surface with a shallow central depression. Smaller isolated droplets are visible near the foreground and right edge, while no developed crown or central column is present.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"99b496e7-5091-4d77-8b77-e5fa1f332b4a","exposureId":"4972a348-77bc-42cd-a8c1-98d025da7f95","createdAt":"2026-08-17T17:18:04.113+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown has an irregular, breaking rim with numerous detached droplets dispersed above and around it. A central liquid column is visible beneath the crown over a broad disturbed surface.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"64ea730f-252e-4b9d-a67d-7d9718a53607","exposureId":"87943ced-341d-403d-a076-116f98f62668","createdAt":"2026-08-17T17:21:11.495+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with beaded rim projections and numerous detached droplets above and around it. The target surface is extensively disturbed by outward-spread liquid.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"5186eea7-80b9-4907-a717-8a59f145413b","exposureId":"14c4cf31-61b9-4dfe-b2ff-344ddf504a5d","createdAt":"2026-08-17T18:00:20.705+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim fingers shedding numerous secondary droplets. A tall central liquid column rises from the cavity and remains attached at its base.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"3eb9565f-74b3-41bc-8d0a-4f65a3109202","exposureId":"f19c4030-990b-4a15-a339-3fa4c3e63a98","createdAt":"2026-08-17T18:00:45.08+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed crown surrounds a broad central cavity. Rim tips are beaded and shedding numerous detached secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"06da785d-410b-4094-9190-6b9d36be444e","exposureId":"93ce81ed-55bb-4140-8c84-4e081ea1dcca","createdAt":"2026-08-17T18:01:33.64+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":90,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A detached, vertically elongated bulb of liquid hangs above a surface already covered by irregular liquid patches and residual droplets. No active cavity, crown, ejecta, or central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":28,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"0d576b94-07ba-4a61-a623-2fc9cf0a245d","exposureId":"13948339-cd6f-41af-ae3a-2ef68e9bb508","createdAt":"2026-08-17T19:30:59.627+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad developed crown surrounds a central cavity, with an irregular rim terminating in ligaments and droplets. Numerous detached ejecta are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"6be22d4a-d87c-4d45-8319-57c18aabdde9","exposureId":"b802157d-83ec-404c-bad2-827368e9e157","createdAt":"2026-08-17T21:17:14.251+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed concentric crown surrounds a visible central cavity. Rim tips are separating into numerous secondary droplets above a broadly disturbed liquid surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"82e5d19f-36e7-4933-b35b-428fae0797ba","exposureId":"74fff6b0-4879-40b7-b333-9f10f50ef77b","createdAt":"2026-08-17T21:19:50.3+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed, perforated crown rises from the disturbed liquid surface, with branching rim structures and numerous detached droplets. Several upright liquid columns remain within the splash structure.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"6658749d-365f-47be-b0de-36c0305d3642","exposureId":"a7c10f7d-f8a6-4e4a-acd5-5a0d4669add5","createdAt":"2026-08-17T22:37:42.052+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"indeterminate","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A discrete spherical drop is suspended above a large, transparent, near-spherical liquid shell seated on the wetted surface. No developed crown, fragmented rim, cavity, or central column is visible, and the configuration does not resolve reliably into a canonical impact stage.","protocolConsistency":null,"contradictionLevel":"unresolved","contradictionCodes":["INSUFFICIENT_VISUAL_CERTAINTY"]},{"id":"f6eafe1f-751c-4dbd-b84f-6d29fdae5306","exposureId":"8025ee50-dbbf-40d4-9834-ac66c367d3c9","createdAt":"2026-08-17T22:37:59.693+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers and detached droplets above and around the structure. Radial liquid ejecta cover the adjacent surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"4c6f5636-10a1-4766-a658-cfa70538ec70","exposureId":"a0513124-6b1a-4786-95aa-2c6bf62834d8","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:24:59.461+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim bears elongated, bead-tipped projections, with numerous detached droplets above and around it.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"3676df01-f1a2-4e57-854d-428d0b1938ff","exposureId":"f6364aba-9418-4dda-b921-2fdc2772b1df","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:26:20.837+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with bead-tipped rim projections and numerous detached droplets above the surface. No central column or intact primary drop is visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"209a0310-66d2-4a2e-bb49-1b8c9ec92781","exposureId":"cfe98a91-21c9-4023-9a46-033a740cde9a","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:39:10.735+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with fingered rim projections terminating in droplets. Numerous detached secondary droplets are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"13f5f8cc-e88c-4408-9da7-b56065355cc3","exposureId":"8490b12a-ac01-4836-9dbf-2429d67219e0","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:46:09.619+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. Rim ligaments terminate in droplets, with abundant detached ejecta above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"e8a3775a-d3c8-4c84-8ba6-02101fdb3212","exposureId":"54544568-3c7e-49fe-885c-6b47553cf0e9","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:47:17.499+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown has an open central cavity, rim ligaments, and numerous detached droplets. A pale arched filament spans between two upright points on the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"e03ab982-4bdf-4e84-a36d-5b1eb0657350","exposureId":"afad3fa0-ea37-4858-b66b-a33e368981b1","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:48:01.88+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large drop and a vertical train of smaller droplets remain separated above a strongly disturbed liquid surface. Multiple raised columns and suspended ejecta are visible at distinct surface locations, without a developed crown or cavity.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"a6f5da0b-f8e3-46ba-9010-50eed3c23d4a","exposureId":"c9ffc6ff-d399-472f-997c-334d49d1699b","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:49:13.516+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed, fragmented crown with a central cavity and abundant ejecta occupies the disturbed surface. Numerous regularly spaced spherical drops remain separated above it, displaying concurrent pre-impact and fragmentation cues.","protocolConsistency":38,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"2f213c30-e4ee-4968-a2f6-8ff10805ff1c","exposureId":"7b8b13a7-da4c-484a-84b7-e2c137f6bdcd","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:50:18.919+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":95,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central liquid column, with rim ligaments breaking into numerous secondary droplets. A disturbed cavity and radial surface ejecta are clearly visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"d0f27a45-5a76-4b0e-940d-b6b8a95021dd","exposureId":"234cc991-d24b-45ea-8ab6-3a373a074ac8","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:52:38.274+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a central cavity, with a perforated, beaded rim and several detached droplets above the surface. Concentric surface waves extend outward from the impact site.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"026edde3-05d0-4af2-afea-83cf655ae7d6","exposureId":"92ac859e-cba2-4494-afff-aa2a66c1c5a4","createdAt":"2026-08-17T23:54:28.706+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown with overlapping raised sheets surrounds a central cavity. Rim ligaments terminate in droplets, with numerous detached ejecta visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"c8f1b108-1fd0-4520-af65-aeab5d5ceda3","exposureId":"967dee17-bdd5-427e-9cef-50884bfeb108","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:01:51.804+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"indeterminate","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A thick annular liquid sheet stands nearly vertical above a broadly wetted surface, with edge ligaments and dispersed droplets. The configuration does not resolve reliably into a canonical impact stage.","protocolConsistency":null,"contradictionLevel":"unresolved","contradictionCodes":["INSUFFICIENT_VISUAL_CERTAINTY"]},{"id":"8a2761ad-f19e-4221-b293-be9317ba68b7","exposureId":"3d792586-45e1-48f5-8acb-21108074c2d9","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:06:25.787+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity. The rim bears ligaments and separating droplets, with abundant secondary ejecta above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"336a7e35-a8e6-48c7-8ff2-7bfa0ebf98ea","exposureId":"5591110d-05b9-4d36-b05f-d8c48ae33294","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:07:19.811+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a deep central cavity. Rim lobes and detached droplets are visibly fragmenting outward and above the disturbed surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"7798e531-08f7-424a-979e-e4b1e0969d1f","exposureId":"780a7de8-f168-4c1d-9d45-0bc000d0aeba","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:08:03.639+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown with a broad cavity rises from the liquid surface. The rim bears ligaments and detached satellite droplets, showing active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"98752d4d-8aa4-4c45-9ead-df8c6a565ebc","exposureId":"ce449bd2-5a6c-4634-a7f1-44ef4e21fe06","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:09:09.418+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large suspended drop with an upward-curving filament is separated from a broadly disturbed surface showing a central depression, radial ejecta, and a partial foreground column. The simultaneous separated drop and developed residual impact structures do not resolve into one canonical stage.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"0276dc7c-075f-4055-ba81-728282cc3686","exposureId":"2906d5c8-883f-4cb1-b1d2-ae9ba57514d0","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:13:08.516+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim terminates in ligaments and beads, with numerous detached ejecta droplets above and around it.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"84f7df19-c057-42d3-977f-aaf90bb2560f","exposureId":"213615bf-6a7a-4c8a-9d56-8b28ba268114","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:15:19.913+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a shallow cavity, with multiple raised rim fingers and small adjacent droplets. A broad central mound is visible within the crown, without a distinct vertical column.","protocolConsistency":52,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"78f40092-9fc4-47b2-bd64-1877ae0f1343","exposureId":"dacc426c-7e43-44f3-a041-dadb396c83ac","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:20:54.171+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with numerous connected rim fingers terminating in rounded beads. Fine secondary ejecta and radial surface spray are visible around the crown.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"50a2889c-4f20-413f-b16e-469d0359f041","exposureId":"a71e2d49-e58e-4a8d-8d6d-329db8342eaf","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:36:26.858+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with rim fingers separating into numerous airborne droplets. No central column or intact primary drop is visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"52108cc6-f293-4cf3-a8f0-e9d1c525bc1c","exposureId":"182d0c80-6a39-477b-9a5c-d66e800a4a06","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:37:29.831+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with numerous rim ligaments and detached droplets. Radial liquid sheets and splatter extend across the target surface.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"4797bf04-c6c7-42ca-a99d-33cdc9b75349","exposureId":"5b5e4645-da41-4d82-af0b-d58b9af2c38f","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:38:33.513+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single rounded drop is clearly separated above the target surface. No contact deformation, cavity, crown, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"ba53607d-f767-4040-afeb-3de09ee8f051","exposureId":"b69b0319-970f-48c9-9e65-cea2f2b53721","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:42:22.666+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown rises from the disturbed liquid surface, with a perforated rim and sheet. Numerous detached droplets and rim-borne ligaments show active fragmentation.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"8e23955f-9ffa-46e8-8aa4-775bf0e940b8","exposureId":"e32f8542-610f-4c88-8cbf-3231f862856e","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:43:33.629+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad central depression, with the rim drawn into branching filaments bearing numerous detached and attached droplets. A separate irregular liquid body is visible well above the disturbed surface.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","SURFACE_DISTURBANCE_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"2ec1ab28-6782-4ccd-87e9-515e75428a72","exposureId":"e3d81a6a-bdc6-4d7e-a3ae-52d3a545d889","createdAt":"2026-08-18T00:59:08.912+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":92,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown rises around a central liquid column, with elongated rim fingers terminating in detached and near-detached droplets. Radial surface disturbance surrounds the impact structure.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"c64d12d8-86e0-48f8-afff-fa69e489ac61","exposureId":"5e32fbd3-f14c-40d6-872f-ee6dd31ed295","createdAt":"2026-08-18T01:26:25.954+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":82,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"An irregular low rim surrounds a disturbed cavity with several prominent liquid columns and inward-slumped structures. Numerous detached droplets are suspended above and around the splash.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"bc4f7a0b-6620-4511-9be9-6a02240cca66","exposureId":"f69a576f-cfa3-4e2a-aea7-847e8ee3f3fe","createdAt":"2026-08-18T01:27:28.694+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"indeterminate","examinerCertainty":86,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Several vertically aligned droplets are suspended above a broad, smooth hemispherical liquid dome surrounded by an irregular annular surface disturbance. No developed crown, cavity, or central column is visible, and the configuration does not resolve reliably into a canonical impact phase.","protocolConsistency":null,"contradictionLevel":"unresolved","contradictionCodes":["INSUFFICIENT_VISUAL_CERTAINTY"]},{"id":"5613e4c2-76ea-46b5-9964-509c18f40fdc","exposureId":"44776b72-92e2-442f-8a6a-b30f45828e52","createdAt":"2026-08-18T03:28:30.576+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall central liquid column rises from a broad, deformed surface region with concentric ripples. Numerous secondary droplets are visible above and across the surface; no developed crown remains.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"d726307e-0dab-4c81-b333-54c8f16d0020","exposureId":"036ddc2d-7119-4374-badf-fe2d823905e8","createdAt":"2026-08-18T12:26:32.099+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall central liquid column rises from a broad, low collapsed splash structure. The irregular rim carries radial fragments, with numerous secondary droplets suspended above the surface.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"568ae625-be6f-4080-a1a9-366eb7792df3","exposureId":"a0530d50-730a-4819-a708-b1adbf099e03","createdAt":"2026-08-18T12:44:03.948+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed foreground crown surrounds a broad cavity; its fingered rim bears separating droplets, with numerous airborne ejecta above the disturbed surface. A second, smaller crown is visible in the right background.","protocolConsistency":59,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"c6a1011a-6e98-4e73-bb43-174ba9a3a41e","exposureId":"7dfeb3ce-5814-4d6f-84f0-ed98c66d2157","createdAt":"2026-08-18T12:50:44.346+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central cavity, with the rim stretched into branching ligaments and numerous detached droplets. Broad radial liquid spreading is visible across the target surface.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"ec54ad90-33b8-4b77-a150-ff9967ec15c4","exposureId":"85fb3f29-4dcf-4ccb-93b1-745568889315","createdAt":"2026-08-18T12:54:50.511+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. Rim fingers are breaking into numerous airborne droplets and outward-directed ejecta.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"5fd52fc0-11ad-4daf-b469-1186eebb301e","exposureId":"b7a9cf2f-c10b-460d-b647-ebf782f543b4","createdAt":"2026-08-18T13:08:54.218+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim bears ligaments and separating beads, with numerous secondary droplets above the surface.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"3e310557-1450-4540-9031-6c6e7b58bce8","exposureId":"a4217396-b0a6-4365-9db7-c2c132cc8d40","createdAt":"2026-08-18T14:11:17.065+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A fully developed annular crown surrounds a broad central depression. The rim is beaded and breaking into numerous airborne secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"84958c4b-fa4a-417f-96d8-fa1a144b8090","exposureId":"8200b076-056a-4836-aa98-0d989f961ad5","createdAt":"2026-08-18T15:43:34.153+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with an irregular rim separating into numerous airborne droplets. No distinct central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"15bee7b0-afdf-47dc-90a0-0f0bcf6f5aea","exposureId":"c2c07328-649b-4cd9-976c-4411399c2afe","createdAt":"2026-08-18T15:50:33.427+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a central cavity, with a scalloped rim extended into ligaments and bead-tipped projections. Numerous detached secondary droplets are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"628df2fa-1f50-4b4f-9ae7-ff7f749a5c09","exposureId":"56fbf9d0-4847-483e-ade5-db79abf3c72b","createdAt":"2026-08-18T16:01:48.492+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad radial splash surrounds a central liquid mound. The rim is divided into numerous long ligaments with terminal droplets and scattered secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"7c614eb1-4ca3-49f2-8196-4ac0e3237a65","exposureId":"eede5281-1825-4d51-987e-3b5c32d0ae49","createdAt":"2026-08-18T16:09:50.093+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single spherical drop is clearly separated above the target surface. No local deformation, cavity, crown, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"c860cc59-3e56-4523-928d-615dc264067c","exposureId":"5a4ed41f-4eac-4521-a864-926ceefc6e1d","createdAt":"2026-08-18T16:11:07.7+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim bears bead-like projections, with multiple detached secondary droplets visible above the surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"701c35cb-8583-4ec9-af49-751b1153a0f1","exposureId":"30bde5e5-dcd5-44d1-bacd-f69ab1398264","createdAt":"2026-08-18T17:12:44.043+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed circular crown surrounds a broad cavity with a smooth central dome. Rim fingers terminate in droplets, with abundant secondary ejecta dispersed above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"cadd806f-367f-4312-a4d7-a19876be5561","exposureId":"42cc6c26-662e-4f40-bc16-28bd9d9be798","createdAt":"2026-08-18T17:25:25.616+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Numerous separated droplets occupy several vertical tracks above a broadly disturbed surface with a pale central impact zone and radial ejecta. No developed crown, cavity, or central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"a76a7425-f1f7-46b6-b0cf-98d1e643158a","exposureId":"18d2faa7-bd36-4be8-b27e-a87f5c9ea6ce","createdAt":"2026-08-18T18:36:17.734+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed hollow crown with an irregular, beaded rim rises from the wetted surface. Numerous detached droplets surround the rim, showing active fragmentation and ejecta.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"55de602d-1ee9-42c7-9302-ed5046fe2af6","exposureId":"f0d4e8cf-46bf-4647-bd8d-d70af37e0d3b","createdAt":"2026-08-18T19:08:29.61+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown of perforated liquid sheets rises from the disturbed surface. The rim is beaded and breaking into numerous secondary droplets and ligaments.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"ab97aeea-df83-41f2-a500-481280e43727","exposureId":"65b3061b-813b-4865-9189-de80b5e887cb","createdAt":"2026-08-18T19:40:31.512+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a central cavity, with elongated rim ligaments terminating in droplets. Numerous detached secondary droplets and radial ejecta are visible above and across the surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"10c10e93-0155-4ed3-b43d-793dddba96f9","exposureId":"f889d955-cc94-4ee8-a45a-c286d335b7c9","createdAt":"2026-08-18T20:10:13.915+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Several interconnected crown structures rise from a disturbed liquid-coated surface, with perforated sheets and droplet-tipped rim ligaments. Numerous detached secondary droplets surround the fragmented rims.","protocolConsistency":56,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"d3bceb8f-f632-4077-9e78-2a8ef7522c05","exposureId":"7a7144ae-8aef-4801-bd88-17283d175e7d","createdAt":"2026-08-18T23:17:26.393+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large drop remains separated above the surface while a broad, flattened radial splash deposit and scattered airborne droplets are already present below. No developed cavity or crown is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"421f355a-427f-4e77-a280-abbbc9d6ea93","exposureId":"d5ebc9cc-6867-4cba-89a5-af2e2aa14322","createdAt":"2026-08-18T23:20:42.308+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed foreground crown has a visible cavity, elongated rim fingers, and detached satellite droplets; a second smaller crown and ejecta are visible in the background. The target surface is broadly disturbed by radial liquid spread and scattered droplets.","protocolConsistency":59,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"c39c9781-40ef-4915-b990-9883e4eea136","exposureId":"2ba78535-5a0e-405d-9bb3-10b924e6f657","createdAt":"2026-08-18T23:30:04.602+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with a lobed rim and numerous detached droplets above and around it. Rim breakup and secondary ejecta are clearly visible.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"4e6bed74-80c3-4d3c-a27e-5c9e79563a37","exposureId":"d7969805-cc49-4bf1-ba45-eb0153f40931","createdAt":"2026-08-18T23:39:27.202+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown rises from the disturbed surface, with an irregular perforated rim and projecting ligaments. Numerous detached secondary droplets surround the breaking rim.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"35050cad-7b55-40e8-b8be-d9d4887f2fa9","exposureId":"fcd5a391-e049-4071-af36-d522e5da494b","createdAt":"2026-08-18T23:42:57.987+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The scalloped rim is shedding numerous detached secondary droplets.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"ff5cf16c-828f-444e-9b81-6e2a6e276a8c","exposureId":"7f685656-ea02-4407-8f49-6e4b2a6113ec","createdAt":"2026-08-18T23:53:59.121+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":72,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Two large airborne liquid lobes are joined by a narrow open-loop ligament above a flattened disturbed surface, with sparse satellite droplets. No developed crown or cavity is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"c6ac3dcd-71e1-423f-8e5c-65dfade94321","exposureId":"d34c5fab-96ec-4fd9-8822-70e12021977c","createdAt":"2026-08-19T01:29:50.076+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"indeterminate","examinerCertainty":82,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large detached drop and several smaller droplets lie above an arched, perforated liquid dome supported by narrow vertical filaments. The configuration does not reliably resolve into a canonical impact stage.","protocolConsistency":null,"contradictionLevel":"unresolved","contradictionCodes":["INSUFFICIENT_VISUAL_CERTAINTY"]},{"id":"bcca4bfd-b116-49ed-87de-ffb98bbb6e19","exposureId":"0464dced-bde8-4fab-b065-48873dbf2d26","createdAt":"2026-08-19T01:31:06.84+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large detached drop is suspended well above a disturbed surface bearing multiple interconnected elevated liquid arches and scattered droplets. The separated drop and developed surface structures present incompatible temporal cues.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"dd2d9352-a8cf-438d-be03-44efd81aa575","exposureId":"b1241a13-74e0-43b9-bd22-3d8f84b0dafb","createdAt":"2026-08-19T01:32:14.315+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":95,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown with a central cavity and fingered rim rises from the wetted surface. Numerous detached droplets are visible above the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"b9ec6de3-6a18-4bce-9825-f2cc3d31a4ed","exposureId":"21e04536-4324-40fd-b474-54f5e6a5941d","createdAt":"2026-08-19T01:56:51.546+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single elongated drop is visibly separated from an essentially undisturbed liquid surface. No contact deformation, crown, cavity, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"d28ecde7-dc78-4dc2-8c9b-ef3804cf70c9","exposureId":"15e7dc3a-b804-4bf8-8de0-7bdd113ceb51","createdAt":"2026-08-19T14:14:50.478+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single drop is suspended above an intact, essentially undisturbed liquid surface. No contact, cavity, crown, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"87b2333f-2ea0-404e-9092-717b07f4b034","exposureId":"21f6ccc6-266d-4dc5-8850-65e1e251e4a9","createdAt":"2026-08-19T15:28:59.041+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Numerous interconnected crown-like rims rise from a disturbed liquid layer, with beaded rim tips and many detached droplets. Several distinct crown structures and open cavities are visible across the impact region.","protocolConsistency":56,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"683ecdae-7efa-4996-9dfa-76c33ad1571b","exposureId":"d8b263e1-5051-4a54-a628-f7214a9e3c94","createdAt":"2026-08-19T15:42:40.15+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with elongated rim fingers and several detached droplets visible above the surface. The rim is actively fragmenting into secondary ejecta.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"bf6eec89-5b5c-41af-bd21-0ec13b43e68e","exposureId":"4957da92-4d45-4696-9fcf-5cdc39ff5565","createdAt":"2026-08-19T16:17:01.687+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single elongated drop is clearly separated above an unbroken liquid surface. No contact deformation, cavity, crown, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"8285e2fd-4e77-4384-be90-74df2837c467","exposureId":"ff638bef-0369-4a59-a2e2-037aae14ba21","createdAt":"2026-08-19T16:43:14.581+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single elongated drop is clearly separated above an unbroken horizontal liquid surface. No cavity, crown, ejecta, or rebound structure is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"2eb8b89e-9d33-44ca-a35a-6eb0b4de329c","exposureId":"417c9c50-be6b-468c-890a-d94ca057ea63","createdAt":"2026-08-19T16:50:09.967+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with an irregular rim extended into multiple ligaments. Detached droplets and outward sheet ejecta are clearly visible around the crown.","protocolConsistency":25,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT"]},{"id":"11d0c468-3104-48bf-b4c7-b112a86381ee","exposureId":"b5e4595e-7709-4ec8-bd46-28825dae8254","createdAt":"2026-08-19T16:55:04.807+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. Rim fingers terminate in droplets, with abundant detached ejecta above and radial liquid streaks across the surface.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"ef2263bb-f855-4e44-80cd-0f50784799c1","exposureId":"72192e1f-820e-4a63-a1a6-23204d24c46c","createdAt":"2026-08-19T16:56:11.466+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large detached liquid mass hangs above a disturbed central pool. Numerous elevated droplets are joined by thin filaments in a broad ring, without a continuous crown or visible cavity.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["FRAGMENTATION_BEFORE_IMPACT","EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"7202069b-78f6-4899-9dbd-ea67cbdc5ab8","exposureId":"0fc86e58-2f62-490f-94a9-93f20940cabb","createdAt":"2026-08-19T17:27:06.695+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large spherical drop is clearly separated above a liquid surface bearing broad concentric ripples and several small raised droplets. No contact point, cavity, crown, or central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"28068a3d-06e7-4a4b-a86f-5ea547ab4ea5","exposureId":"a7816624-0cc8-4496-837f-b736701615d7","createdAt":"2026-08-19T17:32:31.6+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single spherical drop is clearly separated above a continuous target surface. No contact deformation, cavity, crown, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"a32f21c0-5cb9-42b2-a6b1-5cfc689a15ee","exposureId":"64358990-4ede-490c-a1a0-ff2913e2b2c9","createdAt":"2026-08-19T17:33:28.263+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed crown surrounds a broad cavity, with fingered rim projections breaking into numerous airborne droplets. Dense secondary ejecta are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"ac1d3ddb-31fd-4c48-a12d-980c71e0c070","exposureId":"6a14288b-13f5-4898-805c-5e0146bdb324","createdAt":"2026-08-19T18:27:01.099+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad cavity, with a beaded, locally disrupted rim. Numerous detached droplets are visible above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"a1fbafed-00ce-4a8d-b4af-2f61cd28e8e9","exposureId":"ecda50d8-91e3-4480-8692-4ed77b9dd190","createdAt":"2026-08-19T18:29:10.743+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Six separated liquid bodies are vertically aligned above a broad radial impact residue with a small central mound. The plate simultaneously shows airborne drops and an aftermath-like surface pattern without a developed crown or cavity.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"3c8ba163-f911-4a9f-9eeb-24bc48117e9c","exposureId":"414e4cf2-bae4-4f6c-be91-352ea43d5d78","createdAt":"2026-08-19T18:30:24.391+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v2","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"fragmentation","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":true,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A developed annular crown surrounds a broad central cavity. The rim bears elongated ligaments and detached secondary droplets distributed above and around the impact site.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"fbc34b0c-6949-425f-bc20-d36b6716fe0a","exposureId":"0b3e3973-0cda-401e-912f-ccf1d912c62a","createdAt":"2026-08-19T19:54:07.955+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct pointed and beaded tips along its intact rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"b8f0ac60-0a8a-408a-ae0a-1dd7a45a8072","exposureId":"14511e0c-a987-4494-a78c-41bce0360d2e","createdAt":"2026-08-19T19:54:47.015+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single discrete drop is airborne well above a continuous, undisturbed surface. No contact, cavity, raised wall, column, or detached ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"31a2248f-0a9c-4699-a12b-8ca471979788","exposureId":"184c1af2-245d-4ed8-aa09-4ecb1c9296bb","createdAt":"2026-08-19T19:55:46.193+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"aftermath","examinerCertainty":84,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A discrete large drop is airborne above a single broad, radially spread impact residue. Detached droplets and ligaments are visible, with no standing wall, open cavity, or central column.","protocolConsistency":2,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"c540ddf8-6877-4ccb-8feb-650719a2e6eb","exposureId":"c168f165-0fae-4349-8c8d-d568d2aaa6e2","createdAt":"2026-08-19T19:56:44.974+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":90,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A discrete airborne drop is centered well above an open cavity surrounded by a raised, continuous wall with several pointed peaks. No central column or detached ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","CAVITY_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"e728f6f2-751a-4cbc-9016-d9b1de299b8c","exposureId":"2a53e6c6-5370-47bc-a363-f296e8c9e58a","createdAt":"2026-08-19T19:57:30.42+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":93,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised wall with formed tips surrounds an open central cavity, with numerous detached droplets in flight. A second, smaller raised cavity is visible immediately to the left of the principal impact site.","protocolConsistency":62,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"cf673918-574b-4aca-907c-564cb0b39b3b","exposureId":"5d50c6a5-a2fe-43bd-83a0-e011fbb0682e","createdAt":"2026-08-19T19:58:34.001+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central depression, with rounded tips along its intact rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"0c833393-1ce0-4b4f-9436-9f6eba6cbf68","exposureId":"ef6a4819-16d2-4223-bca6-3197e011a8e0","createdAt":"2026-08-19T19:59:35.005+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised liquid wall surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct beaded tips around the rim. Multiple detached droplets are airborne above the intact wall.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"2268a92e-0533-4c6e-a48f-6d723cf36407","exposureId":"db26fe24-cc67-4144-a136-ceb826d51f50","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:00:39.761+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised circular wall surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct spikes and beaded tips along its rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the intact wall.","protocolConsistency":52,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"c8729fd7-c088-4b04-9ea6-19848dd69af4","exposureId":"9d73c584-4a30-4fc1-aa59-65be47349af4","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:01:33.411+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A broad, continuous raised liquid rim is supported above the target by a central vertical column. Beaded tips line the intact rim, with numerous detached droplets in flight.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"4b932aae-0713-4453-8b7d-f4ab0995c666","exposureId":"85956d72-2c96-4876-885d-ccea0831b1b0","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:03:36.798+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised wall surrounds an open central cavity, with developed points and elongated rim tips. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the crown; no central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"4011a260-f63b-42c4-aba3-429e81bcc5fc","exposureId":"948c401a-aa58-45d8-a685-8a8c242fb31a","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:07:00.56+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall continuous annular wall with resolved beaded tips surrounds an open cavity, with numerous detached droplets in flight. A smaller continuous raised annular structure stands concentrically within the cavity; no central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"f26c2add-aff8-4ad8-8cda-b3528f2f3559","exposureId":"1e8b368e-ea96-4c40-82bb-e0b11cf3073d","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:08:21.522+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct rim tips and numerous detached droplets in flight. No central column or broken wall segments are visible.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"c2ed8758-4c9d-4b81-9d28-33777b4a1321","exposureId":"c7942c77-f818-4b7d-bc46-59c7c58d8c63","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:12:13.073+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct spikes and beaded tips along its rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the structure; no central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"7638c396-d085-4188-8131-08794c82f849","exposureId":"208fecdb-6e2e-4ae2-90bc-c1c461b556e7","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:12:23.682+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised wall surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct beaded tips along its upper edge. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the intact crown.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"6e1e6dca-7be3-4aaa-9f69-ab521a748dc8","exposureId":"83e4bd20-2116-474a-ae15-b2e1db1c4c81","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:12:51.667+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown with resolved tips surrounds an open central cavity. Numerous detached droplets and one large discrete airborne drop are visible above the impact site.","protocolConsistency":52,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"a4f1e12f-e00c-4e6e-a0d6-4688795a6ade","exposureId":"455777a0-7926-4caa-80d3-16f8a3111a9e","createdAt":"2026-08-19T20:22:58.222+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct spikes and beaded tips along the rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the structure.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"b36e4c82-0e60-45f2-8ec7-6a023d6e66c2","exposureId":"6bfc05b6-c09b-40e0-beee-0c018c60d1dc","createdAt":"2026-08-19T21:39:50.133+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with resolved pointed and beaded tips. Numerous detached droplets are airborne; no broken wall, central column, or rebound drop is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"c81e2423-9cf6-4536-b830-9d13b7f1d31a","exposureId":"51c4531c-5000-4cf6-a3b6-835c6acdd38c","createdAt":"2026-08-19T21:40:49.757+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with pronounced tips extending into a filamentous, beaded network. Detached droplets and widespread surface spatter are visible; no central column is present.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"2e457b5f-c330-4b91-aeb9-90ea5f923dda","exposureId":"16972923-6148-48ab-b6ac-e8edfe1a0981","createdAt":"2026-08-19T21:53:07.652+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A tall, continuous liquid crown surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct rounded tips along its rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the intact wall.","protocolConsistency":52,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"2b4fb9d3-6db2-401d-a4e8-b7d0fa54fc78","exposureId":"8bc77ec7-3a30-4f6c-9fdf-735247b30e1d","createdAt":"2026-08-19T23:24:12.329+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with numerous formed rim tips and detached droplets in flight. No separated wall masses or central rebound column are visible.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"3039d2fc-45c6-4313-8db7-7942ac8bec06","exposureId":"eca46387-7c9d-4fd4-b70d-cef44b2fb35a","createdAt":"2026-08-20T13:33:42.412+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":94,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised red-liquid wall surrounds a broad central dome, with distinct points and beaded tips along the rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne above and around the intact wall.","protocolConsistency":52,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"d1279484-9f5f-4bde-9a56-776821f6f1a3","exposureId":"dac92e1b-37d1-48f7-988a-48b2dfeb0d9a","createdAt":"2026-08-20T13:36:49.118+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised wall surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct beaded tips along the rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne above and around the intact crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"7575beaa-2d61-4d12-8e97-a273836ab868","exposureId":"b6ff628c-b4a0-4c20-8586-63e99fd61438","createdAt":"2026-08-20T13:39:02.988+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":88,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with rounded tips and several detached droplets in flight. A smooth liquid arch spans between two points on the rim.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"0cdfd47b-249a-4cd8-9151-c067069c37d4","exposureId":"222de7d2-4ada-410e-a843-59104e306156","createdAt":"2026-08-20T13:39:57.19+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised liquid wall surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct rounded tips along its upper edge. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the intact crown.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"7861ec5a-f458-4436-90b8-c0bf396031ce","exposureId":"299cb1d5-87cc-443e-bba2-be2e4d3f4783","createdAt":"2026-08-20T15:50:20.735+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"collapse","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open cavity, with formed beaded tips and numerous detached droplets in flight. A short central column carries a discrete drop at its top; the wall remains joined around the impact site.","protocolConsistency":36,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MAJOR","REBOUND_DURING_EMERGENCE"]},{"id":"ab54dfbb-0b86-4599-a360-2566293f8344","exposureId":"7c400e75-fc7c-435e-b228-72111fe715d1","createdAt":"2026-08-20T18:46:43.47+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":92,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"Several raised, pointed crown walls stand at distinct sites across the liquid-coated surface, with open central cavities. Numerous detached droplets are airborne; the visible walls remain joined rather than fragmented.","protocolConsistency":62,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"ca4f52f3-ee3a-418d-a677-0aeb7bd38329","exposureId":"b342bf40-c1e1-4fd1-ac9f-23d595187e52","createdAt":"2026-08-20T18:47:37.168+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":97,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown with resolved tips surrounds an open central cavity. Numerous detached droplets are airborne above and around the intact wall.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"0440e600-9291-4777-9b23-0d1ce4da871a","exposureId":"c15eb675-dfa3-4468-b9e8-1bcd86db8c06","createdAt":"2026-08-20T22:07:22.503+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single elongated drop is airborne above a continuous, level target surface. No contact, depression, cavity, raised wall, or detached ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"1ffbbb7c-a08c-48ab-9a95-2241e9c87199","exposureId":"b8219c5c-20a7-4cd8-9449-1934f4f11a01","createdAt":"2026-08-20T22:07:53.117+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with distinct spikes and beaded tips along its rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne above and around the crown.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"5c3bc8b3-c7dd-4c50-92b5-58a7855b0546","exposureId":"ed4cd55e-c9ca-4243-9426-a441da92f3cc","createdAt":"2026-08-21T00:22:33.112+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A single discrete drop is airborne above a continuous surface. No contact, depression, cavity, raised wall, column, or detached ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"48cbe9f9-564f-475f-a1c7-9494ea6951df","exposureId":"9aee64b0-a8e9-464a-999a-49772497097b","createdAt":"2026-08-21T00:39:58.434+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":true,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds a broad central cavity, with resolved spikes and beaded tips along its rim. Numerous detached droplets are airborne above and around the structure.","protocolConsistency":86,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MINOR"]},{"id":"a4e73d59-ab24-4c34-885d-3da90e45e36c","exposureId":"c13ef73e-d983-4df8-8e68-98fb1439242b","createdAt":"2026-08-21T00:41:30.232+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":91,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A discrete drop is airborne above a single, already disturbed impact site. A low continuous raised rim and detached ejecta surround the broad radial splash deposit; no cavity or central column is visible.","protocolConsistency":0,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["EJECTA_BEFORE_IMPACT","CROWN_BEFORE_IMPACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","BROKEN_SURFACE_BEFORE_IMPACT"]},{"id":"ad3b401d-c6f5-4c60-8247-5d7cb42177c9","exposureId":"0122b182-dbcb-4340-bcfb-03ef89019054","createdAt":"2026-08-21T02:12:48.658+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with several formed spikes and rounded tips. No detached wall segments or central column are visible.","protocolConsistency":52,"contradictionLevel":"moderate","contradictionCodes":["DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"c6b59583-b1dc-4eaf-8e91-209d3f9c800b","exposureId":"e7b024d5-d7a5-4c81-a7b4-9d39e103feaf","createdAt":"2026-08-21T02:13:13.122+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"coronet","examinerCertainty":98,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A continuous raised crown surrounds an open central cavity, with formed tips along its irregular upper edge. Numerous detached droplets are airborne around the intact wall.","protocolConsistency":68,"contradictionLevel":"low","contradictionCodes":["PHASE_MISMATCH_MODERATE"]},{"id":"46123f77-6df4-4f41-a544-b458868e58c2","exposureId":"03e88806-262f-401e-8f4f-42390c6a38f0","createdAt":"2026-08-21T02:13:39.302+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A discrete elongated drop is suspended above a continuous, undisturbed liquid surface. No contact, depression, cavity, raised wall, column, or ejecta is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]},{"id":"2104a1ae-afd9-4577-9c5a-0f0a73127b21","exposureId":"bd77a73e-696c-4edf-a1a6-636753f896bf","createdAt":"2026-08-21T02:14:51.015+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"multiple-states","examinerCertainty":96,"features":{"crownVisible":true,"cavityVisible":true,"surfaceUnbroken":false,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":true,"centralColumnVisible":true,"multipleImpactEvents":true,"secondaryEjectaVisible":true,"primaryDropAboveSurface":false,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A large continuous crown with formed tips surrounds an open central cavity, with numerous detached droplets in flight. A separate small impact site at lower right carries a central jet and rebound droplets.","protocolConsistency":8,"contradictionLevel":"high","contradictionCodes":["REBOUND_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","MULTIPLE_TEMPORAL_STATES","DEVELOPED_CROWN_AT_INITIAL_CONTACT","MULTIPLE_IMPACT_EVENTS"]},{"id":"aad2a2d7-7d16-47cd-be9e-ba90595b8c19","exposureId":"a3efc7c8-2880-4098-8a82-9aa5ef428ded","createdAt":"2026-08-21T04:18:32.551+00:00","status":"complete","examinerEra":"EXAMINER I","examinerModel":"gpt-5.6","examinerPromptVersion":"blind-plate-v3","protocolVersion":"ec-causality-v1","observedPhase":"pre-impact","examinerCertainty":99,"features":{"crownVisible":false,"cavityVisible":false,"surfaceUnbroken":true,"surfaceDepression":false,"reboundDropVisible":false,"centralColumnVisible":false,"multipleImpactEvents":false,"secondaryEjectaVisible":false,"primaryDropAboveSurface":true,"rimFragmentationVisible":false,"primaryDropContactingSurface":false},"observation":"A pendant red drop hangs well above a flat, continuous target surface. No contact or surface deformation is visible.","protocolConsistency":100,"contradictionLevel":"none","contradictionCodes":[]}],"nextAfter":"2026-08-21T04:18:32.551+00:00|aad2a2d7-7d16-47cd-be9e-ba90595b8c19"}